首页 > 过刊浏览>2022年第59卷第3期 >654-665. DOI:10.11766/trxb202011100503
PDF HTML阅读 XML下载 导出引用 引用提醒
土壤中钨的环境行为与潜在风险：研究进展与展望
作者:
中图分类号:

X53

基金项目:

国家自然科学基金项目（41907015）资助


A Review on the Environmental Behavior and Potential Risk of Tungsten in Soils: Progress and Prospects
Author:
  • 摘要
    • | |
  • 访问统计
    • |
  • 参考文献 [88]
    • |
  • 相似文献 [20]
    • |
  • 引证文献
    • | |
  • 文章评论
    摘要:

    钨（W）已被美国环境保护署（EPA）列为一种新兴污染物。钨可通过多种途径在土壤中累积，进一步对土壤环境和生物生态系统造成潜在危害，而目前人类对土壤中钨的赋存、生物地球化学循环和生态风险等方面的认识严重不足。结合国内外研究进展和本课题组的试验数据，系统梳理了典型区域土壤钨含量水平、钨在土壤中的环境界面行为以及钨在生物中的富集特征和潜在健康风险。指出目前该研究领域存在的科学问题与研究方向，旨在呼吁更多学者关注土壤系统中钨的生态环境风险、生物地球化学过程及风险管控与治理修复。

    Abstract:

    Tungsten has been listed as an emerging contaminant by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Tungsten can accumulate in soils through multiple avenues, creating potential damages to soil and biological ecosystems. However, our understanding of the occurrence, biogeochemical cycling and ecological risk of soil tungsten are limited. Based on previous research progresses and our experimental data, this paper systematically summarizes the content levels of tungsten in typical soils, tungsten’s environmental interface behaviors, as well as its accumulations and health risks to biological ecosystems. Finally, we highlight scientific problems and key research directions for future studies and call for more attention on the (i) ecological and environmental risks, (ii) biogeochemical processes, and (iii) risk management and remediation of soil tungsten.

    参考文献
    [1] Li C Y. Properties and applications of nonferrous metals-Tungsten(I)[J]. Nonferrous Metals Science and Engineering,1987,1(1):65-67.[李承元. 有色金属的性质和用途(一)钨[J]. 有色金属科学与工程,1987,1(1):65-67.]
    [2] Koutsospyros A,Braida W,Christodoulatos C,et al. A review of tungsten:From environmental obscurity to scrutiny[J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials,2006,136(1):1-19.
    [3] Zhu H L,Zhang L P,Du L,et al. The geochemical behavior of tungsten and the genesis of tungsten deposits in South China[J]. Acta Petrologica Sinica,2020,36(1):13-22.[祝红丽,张丽鹏,杜龙,等. 钨的地球化学性质与华南地区钨矿成因[J]. 岩石学报,2020,36(1):13-22.]
    [4] Ministry of Natural Resources of the People's Republic of China. Ministry of Natural Resources and Ministry of Industry and Information Technology release the 2020 total production control index of rare earth and tungsten ore(the first batch)[OL]. 2020. http://gi.mnr.gov.cn/202002/t20200219_2499345.html.[中华人民共和国自然资源部. 自然资源部工业和信息化部关于下达2020年度稀土矿钨矿开采总量控制指标(第一批)的通知[OL]. 2020. http://gi.mnr.gov.cn/202002/t20200219_2499345.html.]
    [5] Bednar A J,Jones W T,Boyd R E,et al. Geochemical parameters influencing tungsten mobility in soils[J]. Journal of Environmental Quality,2008,37(1):229-233.
    [6] Datta S,Vero S E,Hettiarachchi G M,et al. Tungsten contamination of soils and sediments:Current state of science[J]. Current Pollution Reports,2017,3(1):55-64.
    [7] Lindsay J H,Kennedy A J,Seiter-Moser J M,et al. Uptake kinetics and trophic transfer of tungsten from cabbage to a herbivorous animal model[J]. Environmental Science & Technology,2017,51(23):13755-13762.
    [8] Sheppard P R,Speakman R J,Ridenour G,et al. Temporal variability of tungsten and cobalt in fallon,Nevada[J]. Environmental Health Perspectives,2007,115(5):715-719.
    [9] Rubin C S,Holmes A K,Belson M G,et al. Investigating childhood leukemia in Churchill County,Nevada[J]. Environmental Health Perspectives,2007,115(1):151-157.
    [10] Zhao F J,Ma Y B,Zhu Y G,et al. Soil contamination in China:Current status and mitigation strategies[J]. Environmental Science & Technology,2015,49(2):750-759.
    [11] Zhao F J,Xie W Y,Wang P. Soil and human health[J]. Acta Pedologica Sinica,2020,57(1):1-11.[赵方杰,谢婉滢,汪鹏. 土壤与人体健康[J]. 土壤学报,2020,57(1):1-11.]
    [12] Clausen J L,Korte N. Environmental fate of tungsten from military use[J]. The Science of the Total Environment,2009,407(8):2887-2893.
    [13] Hällström L P B,Alakangas L,Martinsson O. Scheelite weathering and tungsten(W)mobility in historical oxidic-sulfidic skarn tailings at Yxsjöberg,Sweden[J]. Environmental Science and Pollution Research,2020,27(6):6180-6192.
    [14] She J F. Applications of tungsten-From electronic materials to military munitions[J]. China Tungsten Industry,2001,16(2):39-41.[佘建芳. 钨的应用-从电子材料到军事弹药[J]. 中国钨业,2001,16(2):39-41.]
    [15] Kabata-Pendias A,Mukherjee A B. Trace elements from soil to human[M]. Berlin,Heidelberg:Springer Berlin Heidelberg,2007.
    [16] Li T. Chemical element abundances in the earth and it's major shells[J]. Geochimica,1976,5(3):167-174.[黎彤. 化学元素的地球丰度[J]. 地球化学,1976,5(3):167-174.]
    [17] Senesi N,Padovano G,Brunetti G. Scandium,titanium,tungsten and zirconium content in commercial inorganic fertilizers and their contribution to soil[J]. Environmental Technology Letters,1988,9(9):1011-1020.
    [18] Senesi G S,Baldassarre G,Senesi N,et al. Trace element inputs into soils by anthropogenic activities and implications for human health[J]. Chemosphere,1999,39(2):343-377.
    [19] Fu M H,Tabatabai M A. Tungsten content of soils,plants,and sewage sludges in Iowa[J]. Journal of Environmental Quality,1988,17(1):146-148.
    [20] Wang S F,He M. Environmental background value and distribution rule of molybdenum and tungsten in soil of China[J]. Chinese Journal of Soil Science,1991,22(6):252-253.[王素芳,贺铭. 我国土壤中钼、钨的环境背景值及分布规律[J]. 土壤通报,1991,22(6):252-253.]
    [21] Lin C Y,Li R P,Cheng H G,et al. Tungsten distribution in soil and rice in the vicinity of the world's largest and longest-operating tungsten mine in China[J]. PLoS One,2014,9(3):e91981.
    [22] Pyatt F B,Pyatt A J,Lane C. The bioaccumulation of tungsten and copper by organisms inhabiting metalliferous areas in North Queensland,Australia:An evaluation of potential health implications[J]. Journal of Health and Environmental Research,2004,3(1):13-18.
    [23] Wilson B,Pyatt F B. Bio-availability of tungsten in the vicinity of an abandoned mine in the English Lake District and some potential health implications[J]. The Science of the Total Environment,2006,370(2/3):401-408.
    [24] Chen M,Li F G,Hu L W,et al. Occurrence and release of tungsten from river depositions in typical mining areas of southern Jiangxi Province[J]. Chemical Industry and Engineering Progress,2019,38(9):4320-4326.[陈明,李凤果,胡兰文,等. 赣南典型矿区河流沉积物钨的赋存特征及释放规律[J]. 化工进展,2019,38(9):4320-4326.]
    [25] Steenstra P,Strigul N,Harrison J. Tungsten in Washington State surface waters[J]. Chemosphere,2020,242:125151.
    [26] Dermatas D,Braida W,Christodoulatos C,et al. Solubility,sorption,and soil respiration effects of tungsten and tungsten alloys[J]. Environmental Forensics,2004,5(1):5-13.
    [27] Clausen J L,Bostick B C,Bednar A,et al. Tungsten Speciation in Firing Range Soils[R]. Engineer Research and Development Center TR-11-1,2011:1-69.
    [28] Ringelberg D B,Reynolds C M,Winfield L E,et al. Tungsten effects on microbial community structure and activity in a soil[J]. Journal of Environmental Quality,2009,38(1):103-110.
    [29] Du H H,Xu Z L,Hu M,et al. Natural organic matter decreases uptake of W(VI),and reduces W(VI)to W(V),during adsorption to ferrihydrite[J]. Chemical Geology,2020,540:119567.
    [30] Sun J,Bostick B C. Effects of tungstate polymerization on tungsten(VI)adsorption on ferrihydrite[J]. Chemical Geology,2015,417:21-31.
    [31] Hobson C,Kulkarni H V,Johannesson K H,et al. Origin of tungsten and geochemical controls on its occurrence and mobilization in shallow sediments from Fallon,Nevada,USA[J]. Chemosphere,2020,260:127577.
    [32] Bostick B C,Sun J,Landis J D,et al. Tungsten speciation and solubility in munitions-impacted soils[J]. Environmental Science & Technology,2018,52(3):1045-1053.
    [33] Oburger E,Vergara Cid C,Schwertberger D,et al. Response of tungsten(W)solubility and chemical fractionation to changes in soil pH and soil aging[J]. The Science of the Total Environment,2020,731:139224.
    [34] Oburger E,Vergara Cid C,Preiner J,et al. pH-dependent bioavailability,speciation,and phytotoxicity of tungsten(W)in soil affect growth and molybdoenzyme activity of nodulated soybeans[J]. Environmental Science & Technology,2018,52(11):6146-6156.
    [35] Li R P,Wang W J,Wang S L,et al. Comparison of two sequential extraction procedures for tungsten fractionation in the tungsten mining soils[J]. RSC Advances,2019,9(61):35456-35462.
    [36] Bednar A J,Jones W T,Chappell M A,et al. A modified acid digestion procedure for extraction of tungsten from soil[J]. Talanta,2010,80(3):1257-1263.
    [37] Bednar A J,Mirecki J E,Inouye L S,et al. The determination of tungsten,molybdenum,and phosphorus oxyanions by high performance liquid chromatography inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometery[J]. Talanta,2007,72(5):1828-1832.
    [38] El-Shahawi M S,Al Khateeb L A. Spectrofluorometric determination and chemical speciation of trace concentrations of tungsten species in water using the ion pairing reagent procaine hydrochloride[J]. Talanta,2012,88:587-592.
    [39] Mohammed G I,Ahmad W,Alwael H,et al. A quercetin based fluorescent chemical sensor for ultra-sensitive determination and speciation of tungsten species in water[J]. Spectrochimica Acta Part A,Molecular and Biomolecular Spectroscopy,2020,229:117929.
    [40] Li F B,Xu R K,Tan W F,et al. The frontier and perspectives of soil chemistry in the new era[J]. Acta Pedologica Sinica,2020,57(5):1088-1104.[李芳柏,徐仁扣,谭文峰,等. 新时代土壤化学前沿进展与展望[J]. 土壤学报,2020,57(5):1088-1104.]
    [41] Yang J J,Wang Y H,Wang J,et al. Microscale soil chemistry of heavy metals:Research process and perspective[J]. Acta Pedologica Sinica,2020,57(3):530-539.[杨建军,王艺皓,Wang Jian,等. 微尺度重金属土壤化学研究进展与展望[J]. 土壤学报,2020,57(3):530-539.]
    [42] Hur H,Reeder R J. Tungstate sorption mechanisms on boehmite:Systematic uptake studies and X-ray absorption spectroscopy analysis[J]. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science,2016,461:249-260.
    [43] Sallman B,Rakshit S,Lefèvre G. Influence of phosphate on tungstate sorption on hematite:A macroscopic and spectroscopic evaluation of the mechanism[J]. Chemosphere,2018,213:596-601.
    [44] Davantès A,Costa D,Lefèvre G. Infrared study of(poly)tungstate ions in solution and sorbed into layered double hydroxides:Vibrational calculations and in situ analysis[J]. The Journal of Physical Chemistry C,2015,119(22):12356-12364.
    [45] Davantès A,Costa D,Sallman B,et al. Surface polymerization of Mo(VI)and W(VI)anions on hematite revealed by in situ infrared spectroscopy and DFT+U theoretical study[J]. The Journal of Physical Chemistry C,2017,121(1):324-332.
    [46] Davantès A,Lefèvre G. In situ characterization of(poly)molybdate and(poly)tungstate ions sorbed onto iron(hydr)oxides by ATR-FTIR spectroscopy[J]. The European Physical Journal Special Topics,2015,224(9):1977-1983.
    [47] Rakshit S,Sallman B,Davantés A,et al. Tungstate(VI)sorption on hematite:An in situ ATR-FTIR probe on the mechanism[J]. Chemosphere,2017,168:685-691.
    [48] Kashiwabara T,Kubo S,Tanaka M,et al. Stable isotope fractionation of tungsten during adsorption on Fe and Mn(oxyhydr)oxides[J]. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta,2017,204:52-67.
    [49] Johannesson K H,Dave H B,Mohajerin T J,et al. Controls on tungsten concentrations in groundwater flow systems:The role of adsorption,aquifer sediment Fe(Ⅲ)oxide/oxyhydroxide content,and thiotungstate formation[J]. Chemical Geology,2013,351:76-94.
    [50] Du H H,Tao J,Nie N,et al. Adsorption of antimony by α-Al2O3-bacteria binary composite colloid[J]. Acta Pedologica Sinica,2021,58(3):DOI:10.11766/trxb201911080492.[杜辉辉,陶洁,聂宁,等. α-氧化铝-细菌二元复合胶体对锑的吸附研究[J]. 土壤学报,2021,58(3):DOI:10.11766/trxb201911080492.]
    [51] An L H,Liu M C,Zhang J Q,et al. Sources of arsenic in soil and affecting factors of migration and release:A review[J]. 2020,52(2):234-246.[安礼航,刘敏超,张建强,等. 土壤中砷的来源及迁移释放影响因素研究进展[J]. 土壤,2020,52(2):234-246.]
    [52] Li Y,Zhou L,Du H H,et al. Co-adsorption of Cd(Ⅱ)and As(V)to soil bacterium Delftia sp.[J]. Soils,2020,52(5):935-940.[李杨,周丽,杜辉辉,等. Cd(Ⅱ)与As(V)在一株土壤细菌Delftia sp.上的共吸附研究[J]. 土壤,2020,52(5):935-940.]
    [53] Iwai T,Hashimoto Y. Adsorption of tungstate(WO4)on birnessite,ferrihydrite,gibbsite,goethite and montmorillonite as affected by pH and competitive phosphate(PO4)and molybdate(MoO4))oxyanions[J]. Applied Clay Science,2017,143:372-377.
    [54] Cao Y,Guo Q,Shu Z,et al. Tungstate removal from aqueous solution by nanocrystalline iowaite:An iron-bearing layered double hydroxide[J]. Environmental Pollution,2019,247:118-127.
    [55] Gustafsson J P. Modelling molybdate and tungstate adsorption to ferrihydrite[J]. Chemical Geology,2003,200(1/2):105-115.
    [56] Wasylenki L E,Schaefer A T,Chanda P,et al. Differential behavior of tungsten stable isotopes during sorption to Fe versus Mn oxyhydroxides at low ionic strength[J]. Chemical Geology,2020,558:119836.
    [57] Ogi T,Makino T,Iskandar F,et al. Heat-treated Escherichia coli as a high-capacity biosorbent for tungsten anions[J]. Bioresource Technology,2016,218:140-145.
    [58] Ogi T,Makino T,Okuyama K,et al. Selective biosorption and recovery of tungsten from an urban mine and feasibility evaluation[J]. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research,2016,55(10):2903-2910.
    [59] James B,Wang G. Accumulation characteristics of tungsten(W)and its potential health risk assessment in the soil-vegetable system under field conditions[J]. Journal of Soils and Sediments,2020,20(2):599-608.
    [60] Petruzzelli G,Pedron F. Influence of increasing tungsten concentrations and soil characteristics on plant uptake:Greenhouse experiments with Zea mays[J]. Applied Sciences,2019,9(19):3998.
    [61] Davies E B,Stockdill S M J. A pasture response to sodium tungstate on a new Zealand soil[J]. Nature,1956,178(4538):866.
    [62] Kumar A,Aery N C. Effect of tungsten on growth,biochemical constituents,molybdenum and tungsten contents in wheat[J]. Plant,Soil and Environment,2011,57(11):519-525.
    [63] Tyagi V V S. Stimulatory effects of sodium tungstate on the growth of the blue-green alga,Anabaena Doliolum[J]. Annals of Botany,1974,38(2):485-491.
    [64] Adamakis I D S,Eleftheriou E P,Rost T L. Effects of sodium tungstate on the ultrastructure and growth of pea(Pisum sativum)and cotton(Gossypium hirsutum)seedlings[J]. Environmental and Experimental Botany,2008,63(1/2/3):416-425.
    [65] Kumar A,Aery N C. Effect of tungsten on the growth,dry-matter production,and biochemical constituents of cowpea[J]. Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis,2012,43(7):1098-1107.
    [66] Kennedy A J,Johnson D R,Seiter J M,et al. Tungsten toxicity,bioaccumulation,and compartmentalization into organisms representing two trophic levels[J]. Environmental Science & Technology,2012,46(17):9646-9652.
    [67] Strigul N,Koutsospyros A,Arienti P,et al. Effects of tungsten on environmental systems[J]. Chemosphere,2005,61(2):248-258.
    [68] Hale K L,Tufan H A,Pickering I J,et al. Anthocyanins facilitate tungsten accumulation in Brassica[J]. Physiologia Plantarum,2002,116(3):351-358.
    [69] Burgess B K,Lowe D J. Mechanism of molybdenum nitrogenase[J]. Chemical Reviews,1996,96(7):2983-3012.
    [70] Wichard T,Bellenger J P,Loison A,et al. Catechol siderophores control tungsten uptake and toxicity in the nitrogen-fixing bacterium Azotobacter vinelandii[J]. Environmental Science & Technology,2008,42(7):2408-2413.
    [71] Tajima Y. The effects of tungstophosphate and tungstosilicate on various stress promoters transformed in Escherichia coli[J]. Journal of Inorganic Biochemistry,2003,94(1/2):155-160.
    [72] Inouye L S,Jones R P,Bednar A J. Tungsten effects on survival,growth,and reproduction in the earthworm,Eisenia fetida[J]. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry,2006,25(3):763-768.
    [73] Guandalini G S,Zhang L S,Fornero E,et al. Tissue distribution of tungsten in mice following oral exposure to sodium tungstate[J]. Chemical Research in Toxicology,2011,24(4):488-493.
    [74] Kelly A D R,Lemaire M,Young Y K,et al. In vivo tungsten exposure alters B-cell development and increases DNA damage in murine bone marrow[J]. Toxicological Sciences,2013,131(2):434-446.
    [75] Strigul N,Koutsospyros A,Christodoulatos C. Tungsten speciation and toxicity:Acute toxicity of mono- and poly-tungstates to fish[J]. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety,2010,73(2):164-171.
    [76] Seiler R L,Stollenwerk K G,Garbarino J R. Factors controlling tungsten concentrations in ground water,Carson Desert,Nevada[J]. Applied Geochemistry,2005,20(2):423-441.
    [77] Sheppard P R,Ridenour G,Speakman R J,et al. Elevated tungsten and cobalt in airborne particulates in Fallon,Nevada:Possible implications for the childhood leukemia cluster[J]. Applied Geochemistry,2006,21(1):152-165.
    [78] Bolt A M,Sabourin V,Molina M F,et al. Tungsten targets the tumor microenvironment to enhance breast cancer metastasis[J]. Toxicological Sciences,2015,143(1):165-177.
    [79] Laulicht F,Brocato J,Cartularo L,et al. Tungsten-induced carcinogenesis in human bronchial epithelial cells[J]. Toxicology and Applied Pharmacology,2015,288(1):33-39.
    [80] Menke A,Guallar E,Cowie C C. Metals in urine and diabetes in United States adults[J]. Diabetes,2015,65(1):164-171.
    [81] Navas-Acien A,Silbergeld E K,Pastor-Barriuso R,et al. Arsenic exposure and prevalence of type 2 diabetes in US adults[J]. The Journal of the American Medical Association,2008,300(7):814-822.
    [82] Yorita Christensen K L. Metals in blood and urine,and thyroid function among adults in the United States 2007-2008[J]. International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health,2013,216(6):624-632.
    [83] United States Center for Disease Control. A cross-sectional exposure assessment of environmental exposures in Churchill County,Nevada,US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,Atlanta[OL]. 2003. http://www.cdc.gov/nceh/clusters/fallon
    [84] Norton G J,Douglas A,Lahner B,et al. Genome wide association mapping of grain arsenic,copper,molybdenum and zinc in rice(Oryza sativa L.)grown at four international field sites[J]. PLoS One,2014,9(2):e89685.
    [85] Huang X Y,Liu H,Zhu Y F,et al. Natural variation in a molybdate transporter controls grain molybdenum concentration in rice[J]. The New Phytologist,2019,221(4):1983-1997.
    [86] Jia T,Jia Y Y,Yu S J,et al. Pollution of molybdenum and heavy metals of the soils and rice near a molybdenum mining site in eastern Fujian[J]. Environmental Monitoring in China,2015,31(1):45-49.[贾婷,贾洋洋,余淑娟,等. 闽东某钼矿周边农田土壤钼和重金属的污染状况[J]. 中国环境监测,2015,31(1):45-49.]
    [87] Liu M. The effect of Mo on human health[J]. China Molybdenum Industry,2001,25(5):43-45.[刘牧. 钼对人体健康的影响[J]. 中国钼业,2001,25(5):43-45.]
    [88] Chen Y Y,Liu W S,Yuan M,et al. Advancement in researches on the absorption,translocation,detoxification and fractionation of rare earth elements in hyperaccumulators[J]. Acta Pedologica Sinica,2019,56(4):785-795.[陈莺燕,刘文深,袁鸣,等. 超富集植物对稀土元素吸收转运解毒与分异的研究进展[J]. 土壤学报,2019,56(4):785-795]
    网友评论
    网友评论
    分享到微博
    发 布
引用本文

杜辉辉,刘新,李杨,罗子佩,雷鸣,铁柏清.土壤中钨的环境行为与潜在风险：研究进展与展望[J].土壤学报,2022,59(3):654-665. DOI:10.11766/trxb202011100503 DU Huihui, LIU Xin, LI Yang, LUO Zipei, LEI Ming, TIE Boqing. A Review on the Environmental Behavior and Potential Risk of Tungsten in Soils: Progress and Prospects[J]. Acta Pedologica Sinica,2022,59(3):654-665.

复制
分享
文章指标
  • 点击次数:819
  • 下载次数: 1954
  • HTML阅读次数: 3129
  • 引用次数: 0
历史
  • 收稿日期:2020-11-10
  • 最后修改日期:2021-01-21
  • 在线发布日期: 2022-04-16
文章二维码
今日访问量：2276 您是第8290620 位访问者
通讯地址：江苏省南京市江宁区麒麟街道创优路298号 邮政编码：211135 电话：025-86881237
网址：http://pedologica.issas.ac.cn/ E-mail：actapedo@issas.ac.cn
版权所有：《土壤学报》编辑部 技术支持：北京勤云科技发展有限公司 ICP:05004320号-1